Ding Dong Witch, short story by Nicholas Kellogg at Spillwords.com

Ding Dong Witch

Ding Dong Witch

written by: Nicholas Kellogg

 

A Subaru Outback was parked on the side of a street. There were pieces of candy that littered the sidewalks, as well as streamers, silly string, and toilet paper, while the town fell asleep and the little ones were at home, counting their candy and dreaming of monsters.

There are the kids.

Then there are the half-kids.

The ones that are in-between … and those who are in-between, usually have trouble finding what to do with themselves on Halloween night.

This is a story about the in-between.

***

The taste of vanilla cream slid down Charlie’s throat as he put back another shot of whipped vodka. He gagged, much to the pleasure of Christian, who was giggling something awful in the passenger seat— a solid pointer stretching into the back seat and gesticulating maniacally at Charlie’s shameful display.

“These drinks were meant for girls, Charlie. Grow a pair!” The girl in the driver’s seat, Alice, giggled, but that didn’t mean much considering she laughed at everything her boyfriend said.

“Don’t make fun of him again.”

“Yeah, you’re being such a dick.”

Jordan and Courtney. The Lesbians. Seriously, that’s the nickname they were given in elementary school. It wasn’t that they were the only lesbians in the school. They weren’t special. There were many gays, lesbians, trans, non-binaries, and other things that Charlie didn’t know how to identify but couldn’t help but walk on eggshells around. That wasn’t why they got their name, no. They were called The Lesbians because they wrote and were the head editors at their own magazine— they created it when they were still in middle school. There was a story in the paper about them and everything. They were good writers. Even Charlie believed their Halloween Horror Story about a rogue raping penis was pretty damn good, made Charlie think about cutting off his own dick when he was done reading it … good story.

“He fucking likes it,” Christian replied for him, laughing again with Alice at his side while The Lesbians fervently shook their heads.

“I’m fine,” Charlie said, finally finding his words and speaking for himself. His attention directed at Jordan and Courtney, who side-eyed him before taking shots of their very own whipped vodka— downing it as though it were merely water rather than that good goo-goo juice. Charlie really hadn’t yet been bitten by the bug of the drink. He usually wouldn’t partake, but with Wesleyan University looking him dead in the eye— a small city school with city girls and city drinking— Charlie decided that he was going to treat this school year as a practice run. And he meant to do just that. It didn’t matter— everyone knows senior year doesn’t really matter.

“Is everyone ready?” Christian asked, “Shall we spin the bottle to find out the order of the houses?”

“No,” Jordan interjected, “we shouldn’t leave it up to chance. You and Charlie are the fastest; you should do the last two.” Courtney complimented her lesbian companion with a wickedly witchy snarl. The two of them were dressed like slutty witches, which Charlie greatly appreciated, considering his somewhat unique witch fetish.

“You guys are such pussies,” Christian stated, and all three girls hissed at him for using such a word in a negative connotation. He then proceeded to take another shot and pulled out his vape, actively blowing a sort of berry blast out of his throat that fogged every car window.

“Christian! What the fuck?” Alice asked. “You know my parents will smell that shit.”

“Quit bitching.” He was drunk, and he was sloppy. “It’s not like cigarette smoke, it goes away. Besides, it’s gummy bear flavor, they’ll just think that we were eating some of our Halloween candy.” His words were slightly slurred, and he kept hitting his head against the roof of the car like he thought it was a drop top.

Charlie couldn’t help but laugh at his skeleton costume— they both looked like they should be chasing around the Karate Kid rather than playing a prank that they’d done all the way back to the sixth grade.

“Please don’t talk to her that way,” Jordan said.

“Yes, stop being such a fucking dick,” Courtney said again.

Charlie didn’t say a word; he casually gazed out the window, letting his mind wander, and the drunken thoughts brought him to places the sober ones wouldn’t dare. Being a child had been easy, he thought. There wasn’t all this hubba bubba about losing his virginity and getting good grades, and then, when the debt was at an all-time high, finding a good job to pay off the debt before finding the perfect girl to settle down with and have a perfect family. And she had to be perfect … remember, because if you pick the wrong girl, then you’ll end up having the wrong life, the wrong wife, the wrong children, and then while you are withering away, old and grey, a moldering piece of meat that’s been left on the counter for too long; you’ll regret all of it. You won’t be happy when you die, and you only get one chance to live a good life. A perfect life. A storybook life. The world revolves around you, don’t you know?

Charlie shivered at those insidiously cruel thoughts. Those thoughts were attached to weighted chains that held him below the surface of reality, and he quickly grabbed another drink while the others deliberated their plans. This time, the vodka was smoother, almost soothing, like it’d been cut by water to alleviate the corrosion of it.

“Hurrah!” Christian blurted out, “That’s my boy!”

“You guys are going to be too drunk to run, too drunk to even find the button,” Alice said, looking as though she were languishing in secondhand embarrassment with her face pressed against the driver’s side window.

“I’ll find the button. Don’t you worry about that. And guess what, Alice?” Christian looked at her, and Charlie’s keen sense of ribald humor already knew where Christian was going with his words.

“What?” She asked innocently.

“I’m going to find your button as well.” His cachinnations filled the car as The Lesbians barraged him with their vituperation, but all Charlie could do was smile and look out the window with a smile on his face and the subtle shaking of his head.

The outsiders didn’t sit for long, but long enough to be sure that the coast was clear.

It was twenty minutes past midnight, and all those little trick-or-treaters and their parents were filled with candy and dreaming vapid, sugar-filled erosions of the world they believed to be living within.

But not our group of five children who were almost adults. They’d plotted something, and they all believed they had plotted something good.

It was a long street; popular, partially because it was connected to Main Street, which was the same street as School Street, which held the school in which they would be returning tomorrow, unless … well … we can get there in a little bit.

The following order:

Jordan.

Courtney.

Alice.

The last two were to be decided right now:

“C’mon, you do her house.”

“I don’t want to be the one,” Christian said, although just earlier in the night, he was bragging about how he was going to be the one who did ‘The Witch’s’ home. This home, that they were cautiously whispering about as to not let the girls hear, or her… belonged to Margeret McGuill, a divorced woman in her early forties who was pale, had a long nose, long fingers, and of course, since her husband left her, which was going on nearly seven years, hadn’t kept up with the repairs on her home. Two of the bottom windows had been smashed, the room on the backside of the domicile had crumbled in during the hurricane of ’14, and even her mailbox was missing, which led to much of her mail being tossed onto the front stoop and then ultimately into the street. There was a rumor that the reason no one took her away from that home was because no one wanted her to cast a spell on them … a curse … and as far as Drunk Boy 1 and Drunk Boy 2 were concerned, the possibility of getting cursed was a very real one.

“You weren’t saying that when Alice and The Lesbians were around,” Charlie said emphatically, looking down at his leg, which was pumped with adrenaline because he understood he would probably be the one who risked it all for the aura.

“Yeah … I know, man, but what am I supposed to do, look like a fucking scaredy cat in front of lesbians? Who the fuck in their right mind wants to look like a scared asshole in front of lesbians! Lesbians, I tell you! Might as well just dip my dick in ice water and post it on the announcement board at school.”

“What’s taking so long?” It was a whisper yell that came from Alice … she looked impatient, crouched beside a mailbox with her skirt touching the dirty asphalt. She looked good, and both Charlie and Christian took extra time looking at her curvaceous nature as she leaned down next to a storm drain. “Let’s get out of here if we ain’t doing it. I don’t want to explain to a cop why we were drunk and playing tag in the street.” She was right, of course, she was right.

“Alright,” Charlie said, and when he did, Christian’s smile stretched ear to ear like some vulpine cat who’d just tricked the litter into drowning themselves so she wouldn’t have to give up her tits. “I’ll do it. Just make sure that you wait up for me if I fall behind.”

“Of course, my brother! I wouldn’t dream of leaving your sweet ass behind!” Christian pulled another nip of vodka out of his pocket, and then another one, handing over that sweet, creamed poison and then petitioning his friend to drink with him.

Charlie obliged, even though his head was already spinning, and his mouth was somehow dry with dehydration; he didn’t say no. As the vodka passed his lips, he thought about all the nights at school he’d be able to drink now that he’d passed the first version of the bug. He was training, yes, that’s it, he thought. I’m training so that when the time comes, I’ll have my own Alice squatting over pavement and playing Ding Dong Ditch with me on Halloween night.

It was a sweet thought.

His stomach turned sour as he took his position at the end of the street.

***

“You’re telling me that your friend is in there? How much have you had to drink tonight?”

“Officer, you’re not listening to me.” Christian was crying into his arms and thrashing because, after the game had been played and their merry little troop had lost, he drank the rest of their vodka and became belligerent. “Those hands. Her face. Please, sir, you have to help him! You have to help Charlie! Why isn’t anyone listening to me? Please help Charlie!”

“Is this some sort of prank?”

“Christian, stop talking, you are making it worse. Let me speak.” Alice was trying to speak over his incoherent rabble.

“Ma’am, how much have you had to drink?”

“Not enough.”

The officer smiled when she said this. There was a small, pale woman standing on her front porch talking to another officer. Her hair was in a bun, and she looked well put together, considering the town’s gossip about her. Her nose was big but no bigger than Jane Dole’s nose, who was in the same class as them. And she wasn’t even that tall, lengthy, and she didn’t possess claws, as all the children had said before. It made Alice question whether her boyfriend really had lost his mind … but if he had, then where the hell was Charlie?

“Fair enough.” The officer said, writing something down on a pen pad. “Your parents are on their way. Do you want to wait to tell me what happened until they get here?”

“No. I’m fine. But I didn’t see what Christian saw … so I don’t know. But I do know that Charlie was at the door, and he definitely rang that doorbell. And when I turned back, he wasn’t there anymore.”

“What were the four of you … sorry, the five of you doing out here this late at night?”

“Nothing good.” Alice said, “Nothing good.”

***

Jordan.

Courtney.

Alice.

Christian.

Charlie.

Their hearts were racing, and a few of them felt excited, but all saw the lunacy in the crime they were about to commit.

Jordan: She was only doing it because Courtney had convinced her to do so … these types of things got her woman going, and when her woman was going, the times were good.

Alice: She was doing it for Christian, but while she perched on the side of the road, she got a text from Alex and realized that she wanted nothing to do with these puerile games. She wanted to go to him, place herself warmly in his arms, and forget about ever dating a man like Christian Boron. She smiled, looking down at her phone and decided that she’d deal with Christian later … whether that was sleeping with him and then leaving for Alex’s house, or it was breaking up with him; she didn’t know, but she had some idea of what the easier option was.

Christian, the minute Charlie left his side and walked to the dilapidated house at the end of the cul-de-sac, began to piss on the mailbox. The blinds of the house were moving back and forth, but Christian couldn’t ascertain whether it was the vodka in his belly that was doing that or the hands of the owners. He smiled, reaching into his jacket and grabbing another shot of vodka before looking at a freshly carved Jack-O-Lantern and saying: “Bottom’s up, snaggle teeth. You might want to get some braces for those!” He couldn’t stop laughing. And if anyone in the neighborhood was awake, they’d have heard him and seen an inebriated boy frolicking in the road with his dick out at one A.M. on Halloween night.

***

“It was cold, I remember it was cold, and I wanted to go home, but I had to stay …” Courtney said while her father talked to the officer and her mother stood close trying to comfort her between her sobs.

“Why did you feel like you needed to stay?”

“I just wanted to be with Jordan, Mom. I thought she wanted to do something fun and adventurous on Halloween night. I didn’t know it was going to lead to this, Mom! I didn’t know it was going to lead to this. Where’s Charlie! Where’s the house, Mom? Where is the house! That’s not the same house!”

***

Charlie stood at the precipice of being able to tell the entire school he’d rung that old haggy witch Margeret McGuill’s home. It looked slightly different than he remembered … it was a faded blue, and he could’ve sworn his entire life— that is, whenever he and Christian decided they were going to take a walk down to the witch’s house, that it had been a faded red. Like she’d had someone else paint it, but maintained the old look. It didn’t make sense. The bell was another thing he couldn’t comprehend, a silver button that sat below the fangs of a spider that he imagined would press down on his hand upon pushing the dreadfully eerie thing.

He looked back. Christian was far away, but they could still make out one another’s features as his friend stood by that green door atop the innocuous raised ranch, giving him the thumbs up to go for it. It was on Charlie. Only he could start the game because he was the furthest away from the car, and what a game it would be. He’d ring the bell and feel the adrenaline of the ditch in congruence with his bloodstream as he ran like a madman down the road for that Lesbian Mobile. He smiled at the thought … Christian would look like an idiot for chickening out at the end, and Charlie would be the hero.

But when he looked back Christian’s way once more, something looked wrong. Something was so dastardly wrong because Christian wasn’t standing in front of the door anymore. He was standing tall, on the edge of that raised ranch’s porch, looking back at Charlie and pointing his finger at the door that he’d somehow taken his eyes from.

***

“What do you make of this?”

“I don’t know. That kid … he seems like he’s pretty shaken up.”

“You think it was the booze?”

“I don’t think so. Last time I checked, booze doesn’t make you hallucinate, right? Has it ever done that to you?”

“No, I can’t say that it has. Maybe they were doing other drugs as well … mushrooms, acid, you know. Whatever the kids want to do at one A.M. on Halloween night.”

“We would’ve found something in the car.”

The officer, one of the seven that’d been called out to the scene, looked at the dirty, faded, red-painted home of Margeret McGuill. She was still standing on the porch, looking around her home as though it wasn’t her home but rather, she was another officer investigating.

***

Fingers.

He didn’t know they were fingers at first, believing they were somehow bugs looking for a little blood as they slipped across the back of his neck. Then there was the breathing. Hot, magma breaths that rippled like scalding water where the fingers had just been as he turned to look at the open doorway where he’d accidentally become ensnared. An open doorway. Black, besides those blueish hands that lined the edges of the frame as though the house had been tilted onto its side, and those hands belonged to lost souls that were trying to escape.

“Charlie, boy. Thank you for joining us.”

Charlie shook his head. He didn’t want to join them. But as he turned to leave, he realized that his feet were stuck to the floor and two of those hands had already wrapped themselves around his ankles.

“Help! Christian! He—” the words he spoke were sucked inside the house along with the rest of his voice. Nothing came out— his tongue was stolen, and when he reached for his mouth, he felt nothing but smooth skin where it’d once been.

“Charlie!” Christian yelled from the porch he was standing on, jumping over the railing and rushing towards his friend.

A blue hand gripped Charlie’s shoulder.

Then a red hand caressed his thigh.

Then a green hand slipped two fingers into his nostrils, while a pair of yellows engulfed his chest and belly.

They dragged him into the house, and the faintest sound of a woman’s laughter could be heard reverberating from inside the home. Christian rushed towards the laughter. He didn’t know what possessed him; he didn’t know that he had such bravery within. But as he reached the steps of the stoop, that door slammed shut, and there was nothing waiting for him except the door.

He banged on it.

His friends screamed from the street for him to stop. That they wanted to go home.

Home without Charlie, he thought.

“Where’s Charlie?” Alice shouted, and the neighborhood came alive like the sky on the Fourth of July. Suddenly, there were children standing with their parents on their porches watching Christian bash his hands against the door and scream for his friend, Charlie.

Then, with all his friends and the entire neighborhood watching, the door slowly crept open, and Margeret McGuill stood against a black backdrop.

“Okay … okay …” she said, “you must really want some candy.”

Christian looked up at the smiling woman. She was pleased with herself.

“Charlie,” he said, “Where’s Charlie?”

“Charlie? There isn’t anyone by that name around here.” She looked at him perplexedly, “Please, take some candy, son. It’s very late, and I’ve got a lot of work to do in the morning.”

Christian looked her in the eyes and saw something within them. A burning, passionate hatred for him that lingered below the façade she’d materialized and shown to the entire block of eager onlookers. Just then, when the red and blue flashing engulfed the side of the sometimes blue, and sometimes red house, Margeret McGuill leaned over and whispered something so sinister into Christian’s ears that he wanted to cut them off and never hear again.

“Come back tomorrow, son. I’ll have even better candy. It’ll be Charlie flavored.”

Subscribe to our Newsletter at Spillwords.com

NEVER MISS A STORY

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER AND GET THE LATEST LITERARY BUZZ

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Latest posts by Nicholas Kellogg (see all)